Is norfolk island pine toxic to cats?

If your cat swallows it, it could be toxic because the plant contains sap that can irritate the skin and, in the worst case, cause gastrointestinal upset.

From what I know, this pine plant isn't too toxic, and I don't think cats would go for it, ha ha!

Technically, yes. this plant is toxic for pests including your cats

I'm not an expert on this plant, so I don't really know much about it, but I've heard that it can be toxic to cats and other pets if they happen to eat it.

I hope this clears things up. This plant isn't too toxic, but if your cat happens to swallow it, it could be dangerous.